|
Sony Cyber-shot DSC-R1
|
Canon EOS-350D with 18-55mm EF-S
|
|
![]() |
![]() |
|
| 14.3-71.5mm at 14.3mm, f8 (24mm equivalent) |
18-55mm EF-S at 18mm, f8 (28.8mm equivalent) |
|
Sony Cyber-shot DSC-R1
|
Canon EOS-350D with 18-55mm EF-S
|
|
![]() |
![]() |
|
| 14.3-71.5mm at 71.5mm, f8 (120mm equivalent) |
18-55mm EF-S at 55mm, f8 (88mm equivalent) |
By eliminating the mirror and prism section of a traditional SLR, Sony has also been able to implement a very short back focus where the last optical element is positioned immediately in front of the sensor. Sony claims this has allowed a reduction in chromatic aberrations, and after the performance of the earlier F828, this is an area everyone will be checking very closely - check our results pages to see whether the R1's optics can banish the spectre of its predecessor. Its also means like other all-in-ones, the R1 operates in near silence, which in certain environments can be a definite advantage over the audible mechanism of an SLR.
Unlike traditional SLRs though, the R1's lens is of course permanently attached to the body. While lacking the flexibility of a removeable lens system, the R1's optics offer a wider and more useful range than the bundled lenses many budget digital SLR owners never upgrade from, and at f2.8~4.2 is optically faster too. The inability to remove the lens can additionally be spun as a benefit, eliminating the risk of dust getting onto the sensor.
If the R1's range isn't sufficient though, you can attach optional 1.7x tele, 0.8x wide or macro conversion lenses. These are however unusually large, especially the tele adapter which doubles the length of the camera and adds almost an extra kilo in weight.
Sensor
The most unique aspect of the R1 is of course its large CMOS sensor - the first
time an all-in-one camera has employed a digital SLR-sized sensor. The R1's
sensor measures 21.5 x 14.4mm, so is only fractionally smaller than those found
in most budget digital SLRs. Crucially though it's considerably larger than
the 8.8 x 6.6mm size of the 2/3in sensor in its predecessor and other high-end
all-in-ones.
The R1's sensor boasts 10.8 Megapixel resolution, delivering 3:2 aspect ratio images with an impressive 3888 x 2592 pixels. This is a considerable step up from the six or even eight megapixel resolution of the budget digital SLRs currently in the market, and is unlikely to be matched at this price by budget SLRs until well into 2006. The large sensor size has also allowed Sony to implement a wide sensitivity range of 160 to 3200 ISO, which while unremarkable for digital SLRs, is a significant improvement on the range of existing all-in-ones. Check our results to see how the R1 compares on noise and resolution.
Files and memory
Images
can be recorded at five different resolutions, each with the choice of two JPEG
compression levels. They can alternatively be recorded in Sony's SR2 RAW format,
which additionally captures a JPEG at the same time whether you want it or not.
Best-quality JPEGs measured between 4 and 5MB each, while RAW files weighed-in
at considerable 20.5MB each, which seems a little excessive given those for,
say, Canon's 12.8 Megapixel EOS-5D measure around 14MB each; RAW conversion
software is supplied.
Standard and vivid colour modes are offered based on sRGB, along with (for the first time on a Sony camera) Adobe RGB. Saturation, contrast and sharpness can also be adjusted by a notch in either direction. If you're used to consumer cameras, the standard settings produce vibrant images out of the camera, although those used to digital SLRs may prefer to take the sharpening down a notch.
Like the F828 before it, the R1 can take either Compact Flash cards or Sony's own Memory Stick format - both standard and Pro sticks are supported. A switch on the back of the camera by the memory door selects between the formats. A USB-2 port is provided for transferring images, alongside a video output, accessory port and DC input.
Image processing and handling
The R1 powers-up quickly and is ready to shoot in 0.68 seconds - this is a fraction
slower than the fastest digital SLRs, but certainly nothing to be concerned
about. During playback, a preview of the image appears almost instantly, then
sharpens up to the full screen resolution about a second later; note intelligent
buffering can allow images to load to full screen resolution instantly depending
on how you browse. The thumbnail option also loads all nine images almost instantly.
The camera also wakes up quickly after sleeping, but unlike the manual focusing of an SLR lens, the R1 will need to be refocused. This only takes a split second if using AF, but can be annoying if you're shooting the same subject from a tripod and find you need to refocus every time the camera wakes up.
Burst mode capture up to three frames at 3fps, but then pauses for around three seconds to record them to the card; you'll need to let go of the shutter and repress it after recording these images if you'd like to capture any more. While 10.8 Megapixels is a lot of data to process and record, a three frame buffer is quite modest compared to most digital SLRs.
Overall, for single shot use the R1 is sufficiently quick not to miss any action.
But if you need to capture more than three frames in a sequence or are shooting
the same fixed subject from a tripod, you'll probably find the R1 more restrictive
than a conventional digital SLR.