Canon PowerShot SX10 IS vs Panasonic Lumix FZ28 vs EOS 450D / XSi High ISO noise
Support this site by price checking below
To compare noise levels under real-life conditions we shot this scene with the Canon PowerShot SX10 IS, Panasonic Lumix FZ28 and Canon EOS 450D / XSi within
a few moments of each other using each of their ISO settings.
The lenses on each camera were adjusted to deliver the same vertical field of view.
The image left was taken with the Canon PowerShot SX10 IS at 6.7mm f3.2 and with a sensitivity of 80 ISO; the original JPEG measured 3.43MB. The crops are taken from an area just to the right of the centre and presented here at 100%.
Note the Canon 450D / XSi captures wider 3:2 aspect ratio images, so by matching the vertical field of view, we're effectively treating the DSLR here as a 10.8 Megapixel camera, delivering 4:3 shaped images.
At 80 ISO, the PowerShot SX10 IS delivers a clean, sharp, detailed image, as also seen in our previous results pages. At 100 ISO pixel peepers will notice a small amount of noise creeping-in, although certainly nothing to worry about. The FZ28 at 100 ISO is slightly softer than the Canon, due mostly to image processing, although this has hidden most noise textures.
At 200 ISO the Canon exhibits more apparent noise textures and a slight drop in ultimate detail, but it's still respectable. The FZ28 appears to be applying greater noise reduction, so again there's fewer noise textures, but also a slightly softer result as a whole.
At 400 ISO both cameras show a noticeable drop in quality and increase in noise when viewed at 100%. It's best reserved for smaller
prints and viewing at reduced sizes on-screen. At 800 ISO, there's another big drop in quality and increase in noise and processing artefacts. The FZ28 tries to smear some of it away, but both cameras are in the same position.
At 1600 ISO both cameras are suffering, but the FZ28 much more so than the Canon. Given the choice most would go for the PowerShot SX10 IS at 1600 ISO, but at this point, neither are acceptable for anything other than emergency use or greatly reduced viewing on screen.
Overall we'd say the PowerShot SX10 IS enjoys a slight edge in this test over the FZ28 thanks to its punchier processing and lower noise reduction. Its crops at lower sensitivities are slightly better defined than the Panasonic, but it's by no means a decisive win in this test - both cameras are pretty close here.
We've also included samples from Canon's EOS 450D / XSi to illustrate the high ISO benefits of a DSLR over a compact or super-zoom with a small sensor. All three cameras may deliver clean output at 100 ISO, but as the super-zooms begin to fall apart at higher sensitivities, the DSLR holds it together. So once again if you want the best quality at high ISOs, a camera with a large sensor is the way to go.
