4xxxx wrote:
For me, the coloured onion seller is better when viewed side by side with the B & W. The B & W does not show the perspiration as much and convey this man is really very hot, also a lack of body moisture in B & W.
I also feel Colour brings out the dynamics and character of your portraits who have such interesting faces. Although the subject is the focal point, colour also adds vibrancy to the surrounding area even when blurred.
I'm not an official member of the monochromophobe party but I prefer colour. At the end of the day, the only thing that matters is your opinion and are satisfied with your results.
Cheers
Some of these work in colour - others don't so much IMO. So for consistency I'm posting series in colour. As part of my workflow, I end up with a finished colour image before moving on to b&w conversion though. Shoot at any kind of distance here and colour washes out due to the atmospherics for 10 months of the year though.
The colour can add vibrancy to a scene, but it can also distract. For example in #4, in the colour version the melons distract form the storeman whereas in the b&w it's complimentary, with nice tones and pop from the early morning light.